I have been meaning to get to
Luke's on the Upper East Side (242 E. 81st St. betw. 2nd & 3rd) ever since I read about them in
New York Magazine a while ago. Well, I finally made it yesterday. They are located in the former Etats-Unis space, but it has been transformed into a Fish Shack. The lobster roll is $14, or you can get a it with a drink, chips and a pickle for $16 (both + tax). What interested me the most about this place is that I love lobster, but I HATE mayonaise, and almost everyone mixes the two - but here you can keep your lobster pristine (no mayo or butter!) if desired, or have it with just butter and/or lemon, and spices. I tried it with lemon and spices... wow, I have to say they don't chintz you on lobster! I was really impressed with the amount of lobster and gorgeous huge hunks of claw meat. (the claw is my favorite part) The roll is nothing special, just your basic toasted hot dog roll, I didn't even eat it. I just ate the lobster out of it with a fork, heaven!!
This is the picture from their website and yes, it really does look like that!

They even deliver, with a $20 minimum. Check out the full menu
here including soups, crab claws and crab and shrimp rolls. I hope they're successful, it's a great addition to the Upper East Side!